Should You Move Your Paid Search Budget Into AI?
November 19, 2026 - 12 minutes read
For most businesses, the answer is no. Instead of substituting one for the other, you can invest in both. Keep your paid search running while building your AI visibility.
The job of AI tools is to build trust when people ask the tool whose website to check out or who to call. Paid search puts you in front of people the moment they search. They share a common business goal in closing a sale, but how they get the customer there is different and complementary.
I understand that business owners want to shift their budget away from paid search and invest their budget into AI when they hear how many people are using AI tools.
Has AI Changed The Way People Find Local Businesses?
Yes, it’s changed things significantly, but Google isn’t going anywhere.
How Many People Use AI To Find A Local Business?
As AI continues to grow and change, more people are finding use for it. BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey found that 45% of consumers used ChatGPT or other AI tools to search for business recommendations this year, up from 6% last year. After Facebook and Google, AI is the third most popular tool people use when seeking recommendations.
People use AI for recommendations in the same way they’d use a friend. Why? Because it’s so easy. You don’t even have to click. More and more people are getting the answer they’re looking for right on the search page. According to SparkToro, about 68% of United States Google searches ended without a click in the first four months of 2026.
This matters because the AI Overview that customers are looking at — the one they trust without ever clicking on a website — is your customers’ first impression of you. And it’s in your power to make sure it’s a good one.
Are People Still Using Google?
People are definitely still using Google. A whole lot of people, in fact. When SparkToro studied 41 search websites (any site where someone can look something up, including Google, Amazon, and ChatGPT), they found that Google handled 73.7% of the U.S. desktop searches. To put that number in perspective, the most popular AI tools combined handled about 3.2% of searches.
In Alphabet’s Q3 2026 earnings release, Google’s CEO Sundar Pichai noted that Google’s search query growth is the highest that it’s been in five years. While AI grows, Google continues to grow.
What’s The Difference Between Being AI Recommended And Paid Search?
The biggest differentiators here are timing and trust. Paid search will put your ad in front of people while they’re searching, while AI recommendations build your brand’s credibility before there’s even a click.
What Does It Mean To Be AI Recommended?
When someone asks an AI tool like Claude, ChatGPT, or Gemini a question about businesses in your industry and your brand comes up via an AI tool, you’ve been AI recommended. For example, you’d be AI recommended if someone asked, “Where can I go to get my reactive dog trained around Elkhart, Indiana?” and your business was included within the AI tool’s response.
You can’t pay for a tool to recommend you. You have to earn that spot. Here’s how:
- Listings
-
-
- Your name, address, phone number, and hours match on all directories across the internet
-
- Reviews
-
-
- Your business should have a high number of reviews, recent reviews, and you should respond to each one, whether it’s positive or negative
-
- Helpful Content
-
- Your website should answer questions that customers are actually asking
AI answers are personalized to the searcher, and they change every single day. Because of this, you won’t see how AI views your business from just one search. That’s why checking these foundational boxes really matters. It keeps your visibility strong and consistent.
What Is Paid Search?
Paid search — also called Search Engine Marketing (SEM) means paying for your ad to appear in search results.
Here’s why businesses rely on it:
- You control when your ads run, who sees them, and how much you spend per campaign
- You can measure the results of your campaign easily and clearly
- Your ad reaches people at the exact moment they’re searching for what you offer
Should You Stop Paid Search In Favor Of AI?
You should not cut your paid search budget and pour it all into AI, because you’ll be walking away from:
- The fact that people double-check AI’s answers by searching with Google.
-
-
- Research done by Yext in 2026 found that after receiving an AI recommendation, 62% of people search Google and 58% go to the business’s website. 93% of people take at least one step to verify the information before acting.
-
- Big decisions are still handled by search.
-
-
- From that same Yext data, you’ll find that 57% of people prefer traditional search engines for sensitive things like personal information, medical issues, or financial topics.
-
- Google’s ad business continues to grow.
-
-
- Google Search revenue is up 12% from last year, now sitting at about $63.4 billion. Clearly, Google isn’t moving away from search ads, so neither should advertisers.
-
- It’s possible for your ads to show up in AI answers.
-
- Within AI Overviews (in the United States), ads from Search, Shopping, and Performance Max campaigns can show up.
Paid search is still one of the best ways to measure ROI. Turning it off could mean disappearing for people who are ready to make a purchase right now.
How Do AI Recommendations And Paid Search Work Together?
Just like any good team, paid search and AI make each other stronger.
Seer Interactive found that brands cited in Google’s AI Overviews had a 15.74% paid click rate compared to uncited brands’ 11.19%. People are more likely to click because when they see AI mention your business and then see your ad, your brand already feels familiar to them.
We talked about how listing accuracy affects AI recommendations, and it goes hand-in-hand with paid search. When someone clicks on your ad and checks out your business, if you have consistent, accurate information and plentiful, recent reviews, that increases their trust in you even further.
What Is AI Location Concierge?
Paid search has clear rules, while AI recommendations are hard to grasp for many business owners because there are many moving parts that are evolving. It takes ongoing work that many people don’t have time for. That’s what AI Location Concierge handles.
What it includes:
- Listings Management
-
-
- We keep your name, address, phone number, hours, and holiday hours accurate on 100+ directories across the internet. We also remove duplicate listings that can confuse AI.
-
- Review Generation/Response
-
-
- We ask recent customers for Google reviews, then respond to them for you, contacting you about any reviews that need your special attention.
-
- AI Answer Blogs
-
- Specifically formatted blogs for humans to read and AI to cite, placed on your website. These are written by a real person who understands what AI tools are looking for.
What Should You Do Next?
Here’s where to start:
- Search your business on as many directories as you can and ensure that your information matches everywhere
- Look at how many reviews and how recent they are
- Keep your paid search running
- Watch your AI visibility over time (running searches every few weeks) instead of relying on an answer from one single search
If that sounds like a lot of work, we understand, and that’s why we’re here to help. Reach out today to learn more about how FDS can take care of your paid search and help your business get recommended by AI.
Frequently Asked Questions:
- Can you pay to get your business recommended by AI?
No. AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini decide which businesses to recommend on their own. You earn a spot by keeping your name, address, phone number, and hours the same across directories. Recent reviews with responses help, and so does website content that answers real customer questions.
- Can Google ads show up in AI Overviews?
Yes. In the United States, ads from Google Search, Shopping, and Performance Max campaigns can appear within AI Overviews. Your paid search can reach people even when Google answers their question with AI. That’s one more reason to keep paid search running while you work on becoming AI recommended.
- How can I tell if my business is AI recommended?
One search won’t tell you, because AI answers are personalized and change from day to day. Check your AI visibility every few weeks and watch for trends over time. Keep your listings accurate and your reviews recent so your visibility stays strong and consistent.